Meet The Oyler Group

We are a positive and helpful partner for buying or selling a home. Our clients benefit from:

  • Having a trusted resource for answers about the buying/selling process
  • Our innovative marketing strategies that work
  • Our expertise about neighborhood features
  • Our ability to target home searches
  • Our strong negotiation skills
  • Having our support through closing and beyond


 Scott Oyler, Lead Agent

513.623.1351 •
SCOTT OYLER is a 3rd generation Realtor with Coldwell Banker. Scott has a keen instinct
for real estate that has grown from his more than 10 years of exposure to the industry,
both residential and commercial.
Licensed in Ohio and Kentucky, Scott ranks in the top 5 of all Coldwell Banker Agents in
the greater Cincinnati area, as well as the top 1% of all Coldwell Banker Agents
internationally. Scott was named in June 2017 by Real Trends 1000 (published annually
by the Wall Street Journal) as the #88 Agent in the U.S. for number of transactions.
A life-long resident of Cincinnati, Scott resides in Madeira with his wife, Kristen, twin
daughters, Izzy and Gabby, and dogs Avo and Maddie. He is a die-hard fan of the
University of Cincinnati Bearcats.

Heather Stallmeyer, Team Manager & Closing Coordinator

513.979.1971 •
HEATHER STALLMEYER is the backbone of the Oyler Group team. Heather has a knack for the
details and manages the paperwork and the contract to close period. Heather is also a
licensed agent, so she has a thorough understanding of the real estate process. Heather
graduated from Mercy High School and Miami University with a degree in Marketing.
Licensed in Ohio, Heather lives in East Walnut Hills with her husband, Ryan, and her kids, Max and
Ava, and dogs Sparky and Ivy.

Erin Fay, Buyer’s Specialist
513.608.0774 •
ERIN FAY has spent the last few years buying, renovating, and selling homes all over the
Cincinnati area. Born and raised in Westwood, Erin spent 16 years in the customer service
industry and became a full time real estate agent in 2011. Erin has a passion for real estate,
and she will work hard to find the right home for each of her clients. Licensed in Ohio, Erin
currently resides in Pleasant Ridge with her husband, Blake, and son, Eli.

                              Laura Benza Wogen, Buyer’s Specialist
513.383.8880 •
LAURA BENZA WOGEN brings more than a decade of residential Real Estate experience to the
Oyler Group. Born and raised in Cincinnati, Laura first worked for GE before receiving her
Real Estate license in 2004. Laura has a vibrant personality that her clients really enjoy. She
works hard until her clients are happy. Laura is accessible and responsive, and she
consistently delivers a high level of customer service to each and every client. A graduate of
Miami University, Laura lives in Madeira with her husband, Justin, their son Henry, and their
dogs Wally and Winnie . In her spare time, Laura likes to ride horses, hike, travel, and read.

Kate Hepinstall, Downtown/OTR Specialist
513.449.0104 •
KATE HEPINSTALL is a second generation Realtor and our Downtown/OTR Specialist. Kate is a
graduate of Toledo University with degrees in Marketing and Professional Sales. Although Kate is
not a Cincinnati native, she has fallen in love with the city and the lifestyle it has to offer. Her
friends call her the "things to do guru" as she is always attending local festivals, concerts, and
sporting events. Ask Kate where to find the best happy hour, trivia night, or burger in town so
you can make the most of your Downtown/OTR experience! Kate resides in Walnut Hills with her
husband, Eric, daughter, Calla, and cat Mr. Bubs.

                                            Jay Ashmore, Commercial Advisor
513.313.9722 •
JAY ASHMORE began his partnership with Scott back in their Bearcat days at the University of
Cincinnati. They remained friends beyond college, and their shared business values and
interests have led to a renewed collaboration on the Oyler Group team. As an entrepreneur
himself, Jay understands the unique needs of commercial real estate clients: from identifying
the appropriate property and obtaining financing, to transfer and/or disposition of
businesses including real estate and other business assets. Jay lives in East Walnut Hills with
his wife, Pam and daughter, Molly. He is an active alumnus of the UC chapter of Sigma Chi,
and enjoys attending Bearcat events and playing golf.

Alice Henry, Marketing Coordinator

ALICE HENRY is the Marketing Coordinator for the Oyler Group. Alice has over 15 years of
marketing communications and project management experience in many diverse settings,
from small non-profits to large Fortune 50 corporations. Alice coordinates the Oyler Group’s
marketing initiatives to ensure our clients’ properties are being seen by a wide audience. Alice
is driven to succeed, and this passion complements the Oyler Group’s high energy. Alice
resides in Mason with her husband, Todd. She has a son, Tyler, and daughter, Caitlin, at Ohio
State. Both Alice and her husband Todd graduated from OSU, so needless to say, the entire
family is often decked out in Scarlet and Gray (especially during football season).



Communities We Serve

The Oyler Group has ties to many areas of Cincinnati, including, but not limited to... 

Madeira, Hyde Park, Mt. Lookout, Oakley, Columbia Tusculum, Westwood/Western Hills, OTR/Gateway Quarter/Central Business District, Prospect Hill/Mt. Auburn, Norwood, Clifton, Northside, Pleasant Ridge, Kenwood, Deer Park, Blue Ash, Delhi, Bridgetown.

Client Testimonials

Review all our testimonials at